Comments on: Verizon’s Silly Commercial Against iPhone – Promoting Untouchability!

By: iDon’t Care | TechDusts

iDon’t Care | TechDusts — Tue, 27 Oct 2009 21:06:14 +0000

[...] week Verizon and Motorola started an aggresive campaign against iPhone by releasing a teaser “iDon’t ads” and trying to prove that Droid is going to be [...]

By: Prasad

Prasad — Thu, 22 Oct 2009 06:13:32 +0000

That closes the argument for me and if at all the agency has thought on the same lines then cudoz. Good point there.

By: Mayank Agarwal

Mayank Agarwal — Wed, 21 Oct 2009 19:41:37 +0000

Impressive observation! I have agree with you on this. Let us see how this whole thing turns out to be. As for me am i still gonna go for touch… i have a problem… i just find the keyboard to be too very dumb and it just doesnt deserve a place around such superior processors and micro chips… I May be the human mind just learns how to use touch more efficiently and effectively as time goes on.. just like the way it learned how to co-ordinate with a mouse and the pointer on screen to utmost efficiency.

By: BetweenTwoBooks

BetweenTwoBooks — Wed, 21 Oct 2009 16:27:29 +0000

I cannot agree with that. By typing on a virtual keyboard, the user is not using one of her senses: touch. We can easily distinguish the keys on a real keyboard with our touch even when our eyes are closed. So I don’t think that a regular user would be equally faster on a virtual and “smaller” keyboard. I’m not an expert on that but I think our brain copes better with a real keyboard because we’re using our senses better.

By: Mayank Agarwal

Mayank Agarwal — Wed, 21 Oct 2009 10:07:11 +0000

well that is what was meant here… no real keyboard.
We type faster on a real keyboard coz we are use to it… being use to a century old technology doent make it superior… and i am sure if a 5 yr old starts using a touch screen then by the time reach ur age he will be equally fast with that..
Paradigms and habits needs to be broken to give way to innovation.

By: BetweenTwoBooks

BetweenTwoBooks — Wed, 21 Oct 2009 09:45:59 +0000

The commercial doesn’t say iPhone doesn’t have a keyboard, it says it doesn’t have a “real” keyboard. I’ve had an iPhone and a Nokia E61i for a while and I can definitely type faster on my Nokia, which has a real querty keyboard. Furthermore, Droid’s keyboard looks even better with bigger keys thanks to its horizontal layout.

By: Mahesh

Mahesh — Wed, 21 Oct 2009 02:06:20 +0000

This whole argument about the keyboard is a bunch of bull $hit. For me personally, the less moving parts a phone has, better it is for me. I’ve had clam shell ones before and soon realized that these moving parts start to break down real fast and are made to keep you switching to new phones. Since then I’ve bought a Moto L6 (http://www.phonescoop.com/phones/phone.php?p=710) phone that worked great for over 2 years. iPhone’s few moving parts will definitely be a huge plus for me over any slide in/out or clam shell designs any day.

Having said that, I dont have an iPhone, only because I dont want to go with AT&T, which has tried to screw me before with their corporate policies. I dont like the exclusive deal with AT&T either.

I wouldnt go with an Andriod/VZ plan either, if its voice/data/sms/mms plan isnt substantially below what AT&T is offering with the iPhone. For an inferior user experience, I’d certainly expect to pay less.

Hopefully the wifi wars will lower the price and the carriers decide not to charge for every little item you need for the smart phone. Voice/Data/SMS/MMS, etc should be one plan, not a bunch of separate ones.

By: Mayank Agarwal

Mayank Agarwal — Tue, 20 Oct 2009 05:15:14 +0000

The whole point of the article was – Verizon is knocking iPhone because it dosent have a keyboard. You said it urself iPhone is fine the way it is… then why you have those commercials running around and saying iPhone doesn’t have a keyboard? I think they could have come up with some real reasons of not using iPhone… like the one you pointed out (30% call drop in NY)

Time will tell but what I would say -
May be 10 yrs from now we will have dual screen computers… one part will act as a regular computer screen and the other part will work both as a touch screen keyboard (yeah… you will also be able to program with that) & a screen (as the need be).. The reason I think this way is I find this a much more efficient and innovative approach than the using a dumb key board..
Again what the future has in store could be entirely different.

By: mike

mike — Mon, 19 Oct 2009 21:41:57 +0000

Just knocking a phone because it has more instead of less is kinda like saying, hey that car still has four wheels I rather go with the motorcycle it only has 2 and 4 is old hat. There really isn’t a comparison. As long as the keyboard doesn’t hurt existing battery life, durability or pure functionality it would be welcome on any phone.

I would also disagree with your assessment of touch screens and moving away from keyboards. Actually keyboards are evolving and are a much needed tool. I could not be a programmer without it. I get the most functionality out of a lot of buttons and very quickly. If I had to do everything with a gesture, it would take me a very long time to do what I had to do. In the future there are going to be many different input methods and we are going to use all of them, not one.

It’s very common for people to think of everything as a replacement when in reality it’s a compliment. Netbooks aren’t going to replace laptops and laptops didn’t replace desktops. Must of us have atleast a computer and a laptop. Just like someday we will use both our multi-touch screen our facial-recognition, voice-recognition, keyboard and eye-tracking, etc inputs all at the same time.

Anyway, the iphone doesn’t need a defense it’s just fine on it’s own so stop knocking every device that tries to compete with it, they all have their advantages and disadvantages. Oh and who cares if the iphone is a better device when it’s got a 30% call drop percentage in New York, thanks to AT&T. First you have to make a phone work before you can call it a smartphone. If I was apple I would sue AT&T for giving my products a bad name.

By: Thomas Wiradikusuma

Thomas Wiradikusuma — Mon, 19 Oct 2009 20:47:16 +0000

Verizon to introduce Droid, against iPhone: http://bit.ly/2Wr0Xu